Scott Morrison's vocal opposition to a controversial offshore gasoline drilling venture meant his later resolution to formally block it was tainted by apprehended bias, a courtroom has discovered.
The Federal Court docket on Tuesday quashed the previous prime minister's December 2021 resolution to dam an extension of the PEP-11 venture allow and remitted it to a joint federal-NSW authority.
That plan of action had been requested by the 2 governments and allow holder Asset Power.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has slammed his predecessor's resolution, made after Morrison secretly made himself the sources minister, as legally untenable and borne of a dishonest and incompetent administration.
Asset Power launched a authorized problem to the PEP-11 resolution final 12 months, saying Morrison breached the necessities of procedural equity and that he was not validly appointed because the accountable minister of the joint authority.
Justice Darren Jackson made no discovering as as to whether Morrison secretly had himself appointed as a sources minister for the aim of deciding the applying.
However he was glad feedback by Morrison offered a correct foundation to conclude that the choice was affected by apprehended bias.
Petroleum Exploration Allow 11, generally known as PEP-11, is a petroleum properly off the NSW coast between Wollongong and Newcastle, overlaying about 8200 sq. kilometres.
Join right hereto obtain our each day newsletters and breaking information alerts, despatched straight to your inbox.
Morrison repeatedly voiced his opposition to the venture in 2021, earlier than and after his appointment because the second sources minister on April 15.
"(The PEP-11 allow) will undergo processes, however I've made it completely crystal clear that is not one thing I help, and you may count on my view on that to be rock strong," he mentioned in an April 21 press convention.
Justice Jackson mentioned Morrison's public feedback "would possibly lead a fair-minded observer to fairly apprehend" that his "thoughts may need been closed to persuasion" when he deliberated on the matter in December 2021.
The identical may very well be mentioned about any deliberation after Asset Power was given 30 days to reply to the federal government's intention to refuse its software, given Morrison held a press convention the day of his resolution and mentioned the venture "wouldn't proceed".
"It follows that I settle for the events' joint submission that a breach of the principles of pure justice occurred in reference to the making of the choice," Jackson mentioned.
The federal authorities can pay Asset Power's prices.
Whereas choices on offshore petroleum purposes are made by a joint federal and NSW authority, the Commonwealth's resolution is used to interrupt stalemates.
The NSW authorities opposed the extension of PEP-11 in 2022 and reaffirmed its opposition on February 4.